On the one hand, Rita's awareness of the changes that the course she had with Frank had generated in her is presented from the very beginning of this scene. Rita has been to summer school in London and she is very excited about telling everything to Frank.
The experience had challenged and changed her in a positive way since she had to face different students' reality without Frank's help. At this point Rita has grown a lot, for instance, the first thing she tells Frank is about the library episode she had with a tutor and how she held back her spontaneous reaction for a politically correct one. It's important to highlight that she has also gained confidence in herself and she feels secure enough to go on with her studies.
However, as all life experiences, not all are roses, she got some negative changes too. After her learning about Blake during summer school, she is quite cocky, she starts boasting about what she knows and she looses for a moment the humility of who is always open to learn.
I want to make a pause, just for a moment, so as to reflect upon us as teacher trainees. I guess that whenever we feel we know something we want to show it off, probably totally unconsciously but we often forget to be humble and respectful towards who teaches us. What do you think?
On the other hand, Frank's attitude towards her changes was the ones of somebody totally shock by the drastic differences. I guess that he couldn't believed his eyes when he saw this "new Rita", more knowledgeable but less spontaneous. He must have felt that he was loosing her, since, he was already used to her dependence upon him. He had already made her part of his life, and the idea of her reaching the exams and the level expected for them terrified him.
Don't you think that letting students go, once you have already established certain rapport is as tasteless as reading the last page of a book, at least to me it is one of the hardest parts of being a teacher?
5 comments:
Hi, JOHI!!!
I think that Rita `s attitude is really irritating. She is back from summer school believing that now she really knows it all and I guess this attitude may be a bit of a shock not only to Frank but to anyone who have known her before.
As regards this feeling of emptiness we may feel when students leave us ( I mean get ready to fly away) I think it is part and parcel of the process of teaching. We are there to foster students autonomy and once they get it we have done our job. But luckily new students come and the story starts again.What do you think about it?
love
lucia
I wonder whether Frank shouldn't have expected this behaviour from Rita, Yoha! I mean, isn't this, after all, what traditional education encourages learners to do? To "grab" and "master" established knowledge, to meet the standards "wiser minds" have set long ago... Why shouldn't Rita be proud of that, at the end of the day?
On the other hand, how ethical would it be of Frank not to want Rita to succeed at her exams?
Love,
Gladys
PS: TOP SECRET! I hope you won't think I don't love you all... believe me, I do, but at this time of the year, and this time of the day (30 mins to midnight, 1 week for classes to finish), I don't really feel that sad about "letting you go"! ;-P
Hi people!
Let's see...
First of all, even though Frank ina way was expecting Rita's education to be as traditional as it could be, we can highlight that he has grown to through the play and his attitudes have changed a lot.
Moreover, I think Fran, and every teacher, should be more than proud of our students passing exams. However, what's the cost Rita has to pay for this?
Later in the novel we will come to learn that she can cope with both, education and her true self, but she is in the process of learning and as every precess she will succeed and fail several times.
Finally, I do have into account that new students will come, but I can still remember the names and faces of each of them. Eduardo Galeano once said that all human beings are fires and there are different types of them. I trully believe that teachers are very big fires not to be forgetable.
just think about it....
LOL
Yoha
What a beautiful tale you've linked us to, Yohana! Thanks! (I've just added it to my online scrapbook right now... I'll keep working to make sure my "fire" is strong and encourages others to start "burning" too!
All the best,
Gladys
PS: why do you say Frank has always aimed at a traditional education for Rita???
Hi Gla!
Thanks for linking my blog to your scrpbook.
Just to answer your question, let me tell you that Frank at the very begining of the book is trying to give Rita a traditional education, since he wants her to pass the exam and to write in the way examiners will expect he rto do so.
As the time goes by, he realizes that Rita's ideas are as important as the correctness of her pieces of work.
I hope this clarifies the ideas.
LOL
Yohi
Post a Comment